Is That Sale Really a Deal? How to Spot Fake Discounts and Inflated Prices

Last updated: September 14, 2026

You see a big red “40% OFF” banner, a crossed-out price, and a countdown timer telling you the deal ends at midnight. It feels like a win. But more often than you’d think, those markdowns are fake discounts built on a “regular” price that nobody ever actually paid. Here at Deal Drop Today, we look at hundreds of deals every week, and one lesson keeps coming up: the size of the discount matters far less than the price you actually pay. Let’s walk through how these tricks work and how to protect your wallet.

What Are Fake Discounts, Exactly?

Fake discounts are sales that make you think you’re saving money when you really aren’t. The most common version uses an inflated “original” or “reference” price. A store lists a jacket as “$120, now $59,” but the jacket has sold for $59 almost every day for months. The $120 price exists mostly to make $59 look exciting.

There are a few other versions you’ll run into:

• Permanent sales: An item is “on sale” week after week, so the sale price is really just the normal price.
• “Compare at” prices: The store compares its price to some other price, like a “traditional retail” or “market value” number, instead of what it charged in the past.
• Pre-sale price bumps: The price goes up a few days before a big event, then “drops” back to where it started.
• Misleading promo terms: An ad sounds like an instant discount, but the savings come as store credit, rebates, or strings you only notice at checkout.

None of these feel like lying in the moment. That’s exactly why they work so well.

The Research: Most “Sales” Aren’t Real Savings

If you’ve ever suspected that some stores are always having a sale, you’re right. The nonprofit consumer group Consumers’ Checkbook put this to the test in its “Sale Fail” study, led by Kevin Brasler and Andrea Densmore and updated in November 2025.

Starting in February 2025, researchers checked prices on more than 25 items at each of 25 national chains once a week for 24 weeks. That’s a lot of price checks. Their finding was blunt: most advertised markdowns were not real savings.

Here’s the part that stands out. In the new study, 21 of the 25 retailers showed “sale” prices more than half the time. When Checkbook ran a similar study in 2018, only 6 retailers did that. So the habit of running nonstop sales has spread fast in just a few years.

Many items stayed “on sale” the entire time researchers watched them. That means the so-called regular price was rarely or never actually charged. If a price is never charged, it isn’t really a regular price. It’s a prop.

Checkbook named Gap, JCPenney, Bass Pro Shops, Wayfair, and Dick’s Sporting Goods among the stores running sales pretty much all the time. Researchers also followed Home Depot, Kohl’s, and Best Buy. KOMO News covered the findings ahead of the 2025 holiday season, and the message was simple: don’t let a sale tag rush your decision.

In a November 2025 WTOP News story about Black Friday, a D.C. consumer expert from Checkbook didn’t mince words, warning shoppers that with many of these sale claims, retailers are “really just lying to you.” That’s a strong statement from people who spent months collecting the data.

Big Sale Events Don’t Always Mean Big Savings

Major shopping events are prime time for fake discounts. Everyone expects great deals, so shoppers are less likely to double-check. And the pressure of limited-time offers makes it easy to buy first and think later.

A Washington Post reporter tracked nearly 50 products during Amazon’s Big Deal Days in October 2025. The average saving was just 0.6%. Some items cost the same as usual, and a few actually cost more. That coverage, picked up by Yahoo Finance and TheStreet, is a good reminder that a “deal” badge isn’t proof of a deal.

Serge Salager, CEO of the website-monitoring tool Visualping, said in November 2025 that inflated prices and fake discounts are the most common tricks shoppers see during big sale events. His company watches web pages for changes, so it sees pre-sale price increases up close.

That doesn’t mean every event is a waste. Price-history data from Keepa and camelcamelcamel on 40 products found that Black Friday beat Prime Day by a median of 5% to 12% on premium electronics. So timing does matter. You just need real price data, not banners, to know when you’re getting a good price.

Major Retailers Sued Over Fake Discounts

Shoppers aren’t the only ones noticing. Class action lawsuits over fake discounts have been piling up, and they involve some very familiar names.

Nike: A 2026 class action claims Nike.com and the Nike app used made-up strikethrough prices. According to the complaint, as reported by ClassAction.org, black Nike Air Max 2017 sneakers showed a $190 reference price but were on “sale” nonstop from September 8, 2025, to March 14, 2026. That’s more than six months without the “full” price ever showing up.

Best Buy: The electronics chain faces new fake-pricing lawsuits, including Morgan v. MN Best Buy Co., filed in the Central District of California in April 2026, and Tanner v. Best Buy Co., filed in the Northern District of California in May 2026, according to Lawsuit Update Center.

Quince: The online retailer was sued in November 2025 in the Northern District of California over its “Traditional Retail” comparison prices. As law firm ArentFox Schiff noted, this case is a clear example of a “compare at” price that isn’t the store’s own past price. It’s a different number entirely, pulled from somewhere else.

Many others: Top Class Actions reports that retailers sued over inflated reference prices include Ralph Lauren, Ann Taylor Factory and LOFT Outlet (owned by Premium Brands Opco), Shein, Sunglass Hut, Citizen Watch, Lenovo, Nood, and Comfrt. These cases cover clothing, furniture, electronics, and accessories, so no category is off the hook.

Keep in mind that a lawsuit is a set of claims, not a final ruling. Still, the sheer number of cases tells you how widespread these pricing practices have become.

Why Fake Discounts Are Still So Common

You might wonder how this is even allowed. The honest answer is that it sits in a legal gray area. As Chain Store Age and DLA Piper have both pointed out in 2026, no law or court sets a clear rule for how long an “original” price must actually be charged before it counts as real.

Is one week at full price enough? One day? A single sale to a single customer? Without a firm standard, retailers can push the limits, and lawsuits become the main way these questions get settled. That’s why new cases keep coming.

There’s also a simple business reason. Discounts work. Shoppers feel smarter and happier when they see a big percentage off, even when the final price is the same. For a store, showing a crossed-out price is cheap, and the payoff in sales can be large.

7 Warning Signs of Fake Discounts

You don’t need to be a pricing expert to catch most fake discounts. Watch for these red flags:

1. The item is always on sale. If you’ve seen the same markdown every time you visit, that sale price is the real price.
2. The discount is huge on everyday stuff. 60% or 70% off basic items like t-shirts or towels often means the starting price was inflated.
3. Vague “compare at” labels. Phrases like “compare at,” “value,” “list price,” or “traditional retail” may not reflect anything the store actually charged.
4. Countdown timers that reset. If the “ends tonight” clock is back tomorrow, the urgency is manufactured.
5. “Sitewide” deals with fine print. Check whether the savings are instant or come as store credit, a rebate, or a gift card for later.
6. Prices that jumped right before the event. A small “drop” after a recent increase isn’t a real deal.
7. Too-good-to-be-true prices from unknown sites. These can go beyond fake discounts into outright scams.

On that last point, the stakes are real. In an April 2025 Pew Research Center survey, 36% of U.S. adults said they had bought something online that was counterfeit or never arrived and wasn’t refunded. A shady “90% off” site can cost you far more than an inflated reference price ever would.

How to Check Whether a Deal Is Real

The good news is that spotting fake discounts gets easy once you build a quick routine. Here’s the process we recommend, and it only takes a few minutes:

1. Look up the price history. Free tools like Keepa and camelcamelcamel show how an item’s price has changed over time on Amazon. Amazon also has its own price history link on many listings that shows up to a year of prices. If today’s “deal” matches the usual price, skip the hype.
2. Compare at other stores. Search the exact model number at two or three other retailers. Checkbook’s researchers stressed that shopping around is the single best defense.
3. Ignore the percentage. Focus on the final price. A $50 item at 10% off can beat a $50 item “marked down” from $140.
4. Set price alerts. Keepa, camelcamelcamel, and many store apps let you get notified when the price hits your target. Then you buy on your terms, not the store’s timeline.
5. Read the fine print on promos. Look for words like “reward,” “credit,” “rebate,” or “future purchase” before you assume the discount is instant.
6. Check the total at checkout. Shipping, service fees, and add-ons can quietly wipe out your savings.
7. Screenshot the deal. A quick screenshot of the listing and the price gives you proof if something doesn’t match later.

A helpful habit: if you know you’ll need something in a few months, start watching its price now. By the time a big sale rolls around, you’ll know exactly what a good price looks like, and fake discounts won’t fool you.

What Regulators Are Doing About Deceptive Pricing

Government agencies are paying closer attention to how prices are shown, especially hidden costs. The FTC’s Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees took effect on May 12, 2025. It requires businesses selling live-event tickets and short-term lodging to show the full total price upfront, including mandatory fees.

That rule has teeth. Knowing violations can cost up to $53,088 each. And on August 19, 2026, the FTC proposed a policy statement on personalized pricing, which deals with companies showing different people different prices, according to law firm Clark Hill.

States are active too. In December 2025, ten state attorneys general reached a $4.25 million settlement with Menards, as reported by Kelley Drye’s Ad Law Access blog. The states said the chain’s “11% off everything” ads suggested an instant discount, but shoppers actually received store credit toward future purchases.

The Menards case is a great lesson. The promotion wasn’t necessarily worthless, but it wasn’t what many shoppers thought they were getting. Understanding how a discount is delivered is just as important as the number in the ad.

What to Do If You Think You Got Tricked by Fake Discounts

If you realize after the fact that a “sale” wasn’t much of a sale, you still have options. First, check the store’s return policy. If the item is unopened and within the return window, you can often return it and buy smarter later.

Some retailers also offer price adjustments if the price drops within a set number of days. It never hurts to ask customer service politely, especially if you have a screenshot.

If you believe a store’s pricing is deceptive, you can report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov or to your state attorney general’s consumer protection office. Those reports help regulators spot patterns. And if a class action involving fake discounts covers a product you bought, keep your receipts. Settlements sometimes pay out to eligible customers who can show proof of purchase.

For suspected scam sites where an order never arrives, contact your credit card company quickly. Card issuers usually offer dispute protections that debit cards and payment apps may not.

Smart Habits That Beat Fake Discounts Every Time

The best defense isn’t memorizing every trick. It’s building a few habits that make tricks irrelevant. Here’s a simple mindset shift that helps a lot:

• Decide what you’ll pay before you shop. Know your target price and stick to it, no matter what the tag says.
• Make a list before big sale events. Shoppers without a plan are the easiest targets for urgency tactics.
• Give yourself a cooling-off period. For anything over a set amount, like $50, wait 24 hours. Real deals rarely vanish overnight, and fake discounts almost never do.
• Trust data over drama. Price history beats banners, timers, and “only 2 left” pop-ups.
• Remember the store’s goal. A sale is a marketing tool first. Your savings are a side effect, not the point.

These habits also protect you from impulse buys, which quietly cost shoppers more than any single inflated price tag.

The Bottom Line

Fake discounts are everywhere, from nonstop “sales” at big national chains to strikethrough prices that were never really charged. Studies like Checkbook’s Sale Fail, the Washington Post’s Big Deal Days tracking, and a growing list of lawsuits all point to the same truth: a big percentage off doesn’t guarantee a good price.

The fix is refreshingly simple. Check price history, compare stores, read the fine print, and focus on the final number. Do that, and you’ll catch fake discounts before they catch you.

At Deal Drop Today, our goal is to help you find savings that are actually real. Keep these tips handy the next time a flashy sale banner pops up, and shop with confidence knowing exactly what a good deal looks like.

Browse the latest deals and discounts at Deal Drop Today.

Read More From Our Blog